Western Victoria's roads are in a state, and with an election around the corner, billions of dollars are being pledged by politicians of various stripes.
But are they offering a bandaid to cover a gaping wound?
On the RACV’s top 10 most dangerous country roads in the state, five were in western Victoria, including the top two of the list. Seventy-one percent of survey respondents listed potholes as their number one safety concern while driving.
As road conditions deteriorate and the repair backlog grows, potholes have become a lightning rod for Victorian voters.
Labor has doubled its pothole repair target to 500,000 from September to the end of January, while the Coalition has pledged $5 billion for roads over four years, including a target of fixing one million potholes.
Ehsan Yaghoubi, an associate professor in civil engineering at Victoria University, said that numbered targets for pothole repairs were needed to repair the roads, but not a future-proof solution, arguing roads should be proactively maintained, not reactively repaired.
How do potholes form? A road typically consists of five layers above the earth: compacted soil, the sub-base layer (which is commonly crushed rock or gravel), the base layer (usually cement or crushed rock) and two layers of asphalt on top.
Typically, by the time a pothole appears the asphalt has deteriorated from the wear and tear of the traffic, allowing water to seep through the cracks to the layers below.
Across much of western Victoria, the earth on which the roads were built is expansive clay, which absorbs water and expands when wet, creating cracks, but turning as hard as concrete when dry.
Aside from asphalt, the layers below become vulnerable when water gets in and the earth expands under the road.
“From underneath, you're basically losing a foundation that is supporting the surface on top, and when that is weakened through water, you will see the potholes.”
Added pressure: Rain and heavy vehicle traffic, while not the root cause, accelerate the damage.
“Obviously, the higher the repetition [of traffic] and the higher the magnitude [of the truck load], the higher the risk of damage to the road,” Yaghoubi said.
Rebuilding and patching: Depending on the time of year and the level of damage, local governments and the state government will opt for temporary patch jobs to reduce the safety risks to drivers.
“If you want to do it properly, you have to see what the problem actually is … the layers underneath it could be a two-metre area underneath that is damaged,” Yaghoubi said.
To repair a stretch of road adequately requires taking out multiple layers of the road, backfilling them with the proper materials before resurfacing with asphalt.
“For each single pothole you need to have an estimation of the size of the area you need to fix and how deep you have to go in. Because of this, there's no way of really costing it without seeing the actual pothole,” he said.
He acknowledged this approach was a far greater undertaking in terms of the time and funding required.
Yaghoubi said major roadworks are undertaken in the dryer months from November to February.
How long should they last? In an Austroads trial of two sealed roads built in 2011-12 using different materials and methods, one at Coober Pedy in South Australia was still in good condition with no need for repair after eight years, while another near Cooma in NSW was severely cracked and had to be resealed after six years.
The report blamed the failure of the Cooma road on the pavement underneath, plus heavy traffic and rain.
Political promises: With such a hands-on method needed to adequately repair damaged roads, Yaghoubi said the promises from Labor and the Coalition don’t offer a long-term solution, and more money should be invested in modern technology to maintain roads.
“It's not like 10 years ago; we've got access to drone technology, monitoring, image processing, and a lot of other technologies that we [should] really utilise [to] monitor our roads, before [they get] to that stage where there's a huge disaster to people,” he said.

